Shel and Robert, at The Red Couch are looking for a title for the book they’re writing on business blogging. Their working title up to this point, “Blog or Die!”, has come under scrutiny for various reasons, not the least of which is that in some parts of the world the choice to blog is truly life or death.
After throwing some ideas around, Johnnie Moore and John Moore both suggested “The Red Couch” as the main title. As John commented:
Don’t get roped into a generic and homogenized title. After all, a good blog is not generic, nor is it homogenized — your book title shouldn’t be either. (Dig?)
THE RED COUCH title is different enough, intriguing enough, and compelling enough to one’s capture attention. Keep in mind … at some point soon the term ‘blog’ will become fatigued. (Double dig?)
“THE RED COUCH: Why Conversational Marketing and Blogging is Essential to Business”
Jim Minatel, the editor, would rather play it safe with a more literal title, such as “Just Blog It!”, “The Human Corporation: How Blogs Improve Everything In Your Business”, and “Let Your People Blog: Why Conversational Marketing is essential to Business”, for some classic reasons:
I’m the one who so far doesn’t buy the “Purple Cow” style titles for this book, even though I love it for Seth’s book… What works for previously established authors like Seth Godin and Malcolm Gladwell might not be the best recipe for first time authors.
And what works for the blog-enlightened crowd that’s reading the Red Couch blog today, might not be the best title to sell to a broader audience that hasn’t yet bought into the value of blogs 8 months from now. We hope everyone here is going to end up liking the book enough to buy or recommend it regardless of the title. But none of you need to be sold on blogging, you are already the leading 1% (or a fraction of 1%) of the bigger business audience. If Shel and Robert are going to help spread the blog vision to business people who haven’t got it yet, the first step in that has to be either them picking the book up on their own from the business section, which I don’t think “The Red Couch” will get them to do, or from your recommendation.
There are two assumptions in Jim’s reasoning that I feel need to be challenged. The first is the assumption that Robert and Shel are first-time authors. It may be true that neither has ever published a book before, but they have already built a large and influential readership. Regardless of the title of this book, it is going to sell well; which brings me to the second idea assumption I’d like to challenge: that the Clueless Joe in the bookstore is the market that matters.
The way people find books has changed dramatically with the rise of the internet. It has for me, anyway. Nearly all of the books I buy these days are recommended to me somehow: by a friend, Amazon reviews, bloggers, or comments on various forums. In the past five years, I can think of one book that I’ve purchased at a bookstore base solely on the cover material. My usual approach when I find a book that seems promising at a bookstore is to make a mental note of it, put it back on the shelf, and check the Amazon reviews when I get home. I don’t trust cover material any more than I trust used car salesmen. I could be an anomoly, but I don’t think I’m alone. What sells me on a book is independent reviews; word of mouth, as they call it.
The uninformed guy in the bookstore is irrelevant. Some of the most influential people in the world are already raving about The Red Couch. Somehow their recommendations are going to reach him and he will buy it, regardless of how silly the title may sound.
So my advice for Jim: Do something remarkable. You don’t have anything to lose.